It was Slender man ._. in 2013 when it was. 

My older sister showed me Squidwards Suicide when I was about 7 -9 ruined Spongebob for me ×D Then we watched a movie about Slenderman. I don't remember the name but I just remember this one scene where this chick is like pregnant with Slendermans child???? But then it turns out to be a dream. Idk it was really weird but scary asf for little me. 

Jeff the Killer!!! 0_0

My first creepypasta that brought me into the fandom was jeff the killer from a gacha story T-T

the pinkie pie one...

def jeff

Me 2 Lol, My first creepypastas were Jeff & Jane the Killer (And then I think It was Slenderman) So basically I was 5 Or 6 And I was scrolling through YouTube! And I used to watch these guys (Dlive22892 & Entowinthepack or smth like that) Play Little Big Planet horror levels, And that how I found my first creepypasta :DD (And then from that I found Jane the killer & Slenderman) :3

Sl3nd3rm@n! I $till luv thi$ ch@r@ct3r (～￣▽￣)～

jeff or slenderman was the first one I heard about, but laughing jack was the first story I actually read. 

slenderman because I remember a roblox game centered around him 

I think mine was jeff! I just remember kids at school talking about him and i looked him up LOL.

jeff The Killer sin dudar. Jajajajajaja

for me it was the suicidal mouse thing in elementary school. A kid left after watching it in school so it was coincidental so we all thought it was a curse or something. Seeing it years later it’s not very scary anymore, which is a lil disappointing ;-;

ah, Jeff man too

Either Slenderman or Jeff the Killer and both scared me shitless especially Jeff, I used to make up different escape routes in my head before bed or thought about how I'd defend myself just in case he somehow came in through my closed window lmao

i think the first i heard about was slenderman, heard about him through my friends

i think it was or ben drowned, jeff the killer or slenderman TT

I had heard of Slenderman (movies and video games), but I didn't care that much, and I still didn't know what a creepypasta was. But then I discovered Jeff The Killer, and I got so hooked that I discovered a world.

Even though I don't remember much, I know that the first one was Slenderman and I got to watch things that I never found again! But after a while, when I returned to the fandom, it was 'Ticci' Toby

Definitely Slenderman. I remember all the photos and videos that were floating around the internet. Also watched all the marble hornets videos on YouTube. Those are the reason I got into creepypasta.

Fue Zero, mi hermana me mostro su creepypasta cuando tenia 8 años,me asuste pero desde entonces quise ver mas

Fue Zero, mi hermana me mostro su creepypasta cuando tenia 8 años,me asuste pero desde entonces quise ver mas

jeff the killer Xd i got into the fandom when i was like 7??? i wanted to marry him AAAAAAAAA but i know i wasnt alone XD

It's probably Herobrine for me, but I found out about a few others like SmileDog, Slenderman and The Rake around the same time.

My first was Slenderman and then a STEADYYYY decline to Jeff the killer and other hella romanticized characters.

it was 2018 and I was on yt then I stumbled upon SLENDERMAN 

cupcakes and I think Jeff?

my older cousin and I played a slenderman horror game on Roblox and then I got obsessed with it lol

ben drowned I remember my friends talking about it in 6th grade,explained it to me then I just got hooked into the fandom.

Jeff the killer 

Jane the killer. she was my first. i really like Harley Quinn and she reminded me a lot of her when i was younger

ben drowned

when i went to secondary school, I met a new friend who introduced me to creepy pasta

the first one ive heard of was Jeff the Killer

I knew about slender man before that but never knew there's a whole ass fandom for it

I was just surfing the web

Found out about Eyeless Jack

Probably Siren Head (Does it even count tho??) Or Slenderman through my fav game Slendrina

hmm jeff the killer!!!

Jeff the Killer, he was my fav and still my fav

It was a compilation of stories on roblox and Jeff was in those T__T