First creepypasta?

Ben drowned I was terrified as a kid (but I also watched a lot of lost episode creepy pastas too)

I think it might've been Slender Man because I do remember talking about him a lot with my friend a really long time ago. We literally tried finding out which forest he lived in.

slenderman probably

Sonic.exe, probably because of the bad sonic phase I had as a kid, not to mention the Gory Tails.

I believe mine was Ticci Toby, but now Ticci Toby isn't a creepypasta because of the creator's wishes.. so.. I think my actual first was Slenderman!

jeff and jane the killer i watched this youtuber doing art and reading 📖 creepypasta 

I think the first actual creepypasta I ever heard was laughing jack. The only reason I found it was because I was on that weird side of youtube with like creepy fanarts of MLP and Disney princesses lol. good times I miss it alot tbh...

The first one I heard of was Cupcakes, but I didn't really have any interest in it.

Then one day while I was playing Animal Jam and saw Slenderman everywhere so I got curious and looked it up. So it technically was my first Creepypasta.

I can't remember the first Creepypasta I was really interested in, it may have been Lost Silver or some other videogame Creepypasta, and that is now why I like spooky things in videogames.

Mine was Su*cide Sadie. I remeber hearing about her from my older brother and it all went down hill from there honestly.

My first creepypasta story that I heard of was Jeff the killer, back in 2012. But the first story that I actually read was Candle cove. 

i cant remeber exactly but it was either jeff the killer or ticci toby lol

Jeff the killer sadly

I was a avid Little big planet player and always played the "run from Jeff the killer" games. I looked him up and read the story (which was scarier then, than now lol)

Slenderman was my first

omgg my cousin told me about the russian sleep experiment when we were both like 11 loll i 100% thought it was real lmao

then after that he also showed me the jeff the killer pic and i ended up listening to some youtuber tell the story. thought it was lame and not at all as scary as i was expecting, so i started to read more pastas in order to find ones that actually spooked me. (now i just like them bc they're silly :3)

mine was Jeff the killer, I did know about slenderman but I only knew how he looked 

Slenderman but specifically from the popular app game in 2012-2013 ish, and the rest is history.

I think it was slenderman? After i found out about that tall guy i got into that fandom

I remember having free internet access as a kid lol, the first ever creepypastas Ive seen that introduced me to the fandom was robobly Slenderman and rainbow factory. They where pretty popular when I was younger and it got me interested into  the whole creepy scene

i dont remember that much, but the first one i think i saw was charlie charlie, it scared the shit out of me!!

slender man for sure lol

i had to think about this one for a bit since my memory from a few years ago is so hazy, but i just remembered! my first creepypasta was eyeless jack. i remember dreaming about the story for a while afterwards in some kind of weird nightmare, but not quite nightmare scenario. hes also still my favorite c:

i found him through listening to a youtuber (probably mrcreepypasta) and i started listening to more creepypastas sort of as night-time stories. good times ^w^

I'd have to go with jeff the killer 100%. i was so fascinated by his story that I wanted to learn a bit more about him, which I did. 

Jeff the killer lol <3 

Slenderman, it gave me a love of lonely forests and liminal spaces.

Jeff the killer<3

probably smile dog and jeff lol. i fully remember hearing about jeff the killer on this draw my life thing and i was just like oh my god yes XD

It was either Jeff the killer or Slenderman 

Slenderman I think was officially the first creepy pasta I learned about. He's the reason I know what creepy pastas are because I knew slenderman before I knew he was a creepy pasta.

But I do vaguely remember seeing sonic.exe and Ben drowned around, though I didn't look into them and had no idea what they were at that time.

eyeless jack i was MADLY inlove with him too

The first creepy pasta i discovered was Slenderman or Jeff- idk which came first but it was one of those two fuckerz

I think it was the suicidal mouse creepypasta

(i didnt read it when it came out because i wasnt born) but Ted the Caver, i remember my friend showed me it and i read it straight away 

Probably Herobrine to be honest.. There was also a mc mod with a bunch of creepypastas, including the rake, who I remember being genuinely terrified of as a kid.

Jeff the killer or the Pinkie pie one 

Jeff

jeff the killer (i used to have a crush on him)

For me it was sonic.exe, I was watching videos on my mom's phone a long time ago back in 2012 and then the yt algorithm showed me a sonic.exe game play sorta thing

Good question. I think it was Eyeless jack. I saw a fanart of him on a fanfiction or sum and it got me hooked XD

For me it was either jeff the killer or slenderman

probably lui woods or someone like that !

Sonic.exe is the farthest i can remember

I heard my first one which was slenderman from Jessi Vee and I have been in love ever since

Slenderman bc of that one comic dub where he had a daughter or smth

Probably Slenderman111!!!!!1!1!1!!!!!!!11!!1!!!

Either Jeff or Slender... I don't remember which one it was tbh

That Pinkie Pie one

probably jeff the killer.. i saw it by accident on youtube and i got addicted

Ben probably

It was Slender man ._. in 2013 when it was. 

My older sister showed me Squidwards Suicide when I was about 7 -9 ruined Spongebob for me ×D Then we watched a movie about Slenderman. I don't remember the name but I just remember this one scene where this chick is like pregnant with Slendermans child???? But then it turns out to be a dream. Idk it was really weird but scary asf for little me.