« News and Politics Forum

The 1 day Economic boycott

Posted by k4ti3z_c0nc1ous(ᵔᴥᵔ)✿

posted
updated

Forum: News and Politics

omkay none of these paragraphs are completed I just hit a wall on typing and being able to lay out my thoughts. edits tbd


So I had some thoughts on the recent "boycott" that supposedly happened. A repost based one day aversion of big companies.

I could sit here at home and scoff at the inefficacy of liberal/non-marxist leftist activism but that attitude does nothing to help steer people in the direction of clear class consciousness. It is the duty of a good communist to build off of people's justified frustration, and help others make the connections that I had made. So I thought I would share some thoughts of mine, because based on what I've seen in this forum, most users are still working on this development. 

Lack of a solid plan of action - This could be on me for not really doing my due diligence on researching whatever org put this together or what their beliefs are, but not having a clearly organized group or demands, is going to guarantee that nothing will change. Collective action must have a clear cut demand from a company or capitalists, and the given action must be prolonged until the demand is met. In the case of the economic boycott, the collective action is a vague non-action, and the demands are just an expression of general disapproval at the state of things. This isn't to say that workers aren't justified in being outraged at their material conditions, the everlasting crisis that late capitalism finds itself is always alleviated at the expense of the workers.

The basis of why this movement seems like a good idea is the prevalence of the idea of "voting with your dollars". This sentiment touches on the concept that the working class (those who only make a living through a wage or salary), the vast majority of the population, has the potential to exert its power over the capitalist class (those who make their money from profits/production assets/capital growth), a very small minority of the population. However, using the logic of $1 = 1 vote, the working class is hugely overpowered. This logic is likely validated by mass media because it takes the focus away from where the power of the working class really lies - in their work. The people who operate the machinery, transport material, process data, etc. are the ones who can halt the system in its tracks. The churning of profit machine Collective organizing against capital must be directed to exert the working class power

What aspiring leftists needs to understand is that action that does not attack the fundamental logic of capitalism will not have the power to change society. The suggestion that a small movement of people not buying something for a day will lead to fortune 500 corporations taking a noticeable hit on their market value is not a realistic expectation whatsoever and is purely idealistic. Plenty of people will not spend money for a whole day unintentionally, 



Report Topic

5 Replies

Sort Replies:

Reply by MrJeff

posted

The only succesful way of making people care about politics and condier marxists views in my experince is to make it intersting for them. Any sort of statment that brings a geniun reaction of shock. It doesn't even need to be leftist it can just be a fact that they might have not heard before.

Here is 3 examples of what I'm talking about:

  • There around around 820 something military bases in this world placed internationly and that the US own almost 800 of them. 


  • The red scare is real and organizations like CIA lied about Communism and Stalin I like to point them to a publicy declasifed paper that CIA has uploaded on thier offical site THIS. This isn't nesserly a defence of Stalin but more of a contrarian view that can undermine peoples ability to trust whatever they hear.


  • A more recent example would be like that of Palenstine where around 2500 college student protesters got arrested many beaten up and not just student but even including Steve Tamari a 60 year old jewish profesor who got beaten up by the cops for being in a protest, just for refrence only around 52 arrests were made in Jan 6...


As for other leftists I think they should consider educating others around them and activily conuter rubish talking points particular those directed at immigrants and find like minded people who already are doing real activism. I would also say that many young leftists lack theroy and/or are very commonly picking on their socialist/communist allys without properly understanding why they won't cooprate with liberal institutions. But by far the most common thing I see young leftsits being divided on is on the concept of anarchism, it's mostly a trap at the current stage that won't challange the status quo.


Permalink Report Reply

Reply by Philosophy101

posted

I found this forum post to be interesting, in the funny way.
It's clear that you are not part of the "working class" you talk about. You really think that they would stop working to support communism? I've worked in the blue collard field, I'm a craftsman and a wielder, and I can tell you that they would never want to protest and stop working for Marxist ideals. First, most of these guys have actual responsibilities, like putting food on the table for their kids, stopping working would mean their kids starve. Also... Why would anyone in their right mind want communism XD, Why would any of us workers want the fruits of our labor stolen and given to lazy bums who don't want to work. No amount of yapping from a kid would convince an adult that a failed economic system that contradicts any form of logic would be beneficial.

You are right about one thing though, a group of 100s of people not buying stuff in a population of 100s of Millions does nothing as a protest.


Permalink Report Reply

Reply by Carboniferous

posted
updated

How many of the boycotters are going to treat themselves after the boycott is over by buying something from Amazon? LOL XD


Permalink Report Reply

Reply by slashzzz

posted

all these boycotts are just an attempt to impose collective responsibility on ordinary people, most agitators do nothing but tell anyone who disagrees with them that they are personally to blame for what is happening, conditionally eating meat, not everyone is ready to boycott, stop behaving like children, most of you will return to "forbidden" goods as Only the trend will end, if you want to fight the system, first leave its victims alone.


Permalink Report Reply

Reply by spicyshark

posted

What needs to happen is a general strike and it needs to be organized around the concept that the politicians you are voting for are not representing you. Leave out all the left and right issues and just simply say hey we are voting for these people and they dont represent us and that needs to stop. 

everyone not showing up to work for a day would have a much larger impact than everyone just not buying anything for a day.


Permalink Report Reply