I pretty much got scared of all of them but what scared me the most was slender and. I thought he was in my room when I was sleeping lol. I was so paranoid. 

i was TERRIFIED ben drowned was gonna, like, hack my search history as a kid and be so weirded out by my fanfics that he wouldn't bother trying to k me lmao<//3

ngl i used to be haunted by the thoughts/images of smile dog and the rake

slenderman

When I was little I saw this youtuber who voice acted little thingys of creepypastas and I watched one about suicide mouse. It honestly kept me up at night and its message kinda freaked me out, I even had this weird surreal dream where I was in a 30's rubberhose animation at a gas station and suicide mouse kills goofy. Then I woke up to watching Croods or something, so ig this was back in 2013 probably. I then at some point went around school saying mickey mouse traumatized me cause I thought it was kinda funny, but the creepypasta definitely freaked me out and I had a couple sleepless nights lol.

russian sleep experiment because I genuinely thought I was going to get kidnapped and experimented on ;-;

SMILE DOG BROOOOOO 

SONIC.EXE

the rake was so scary lol

definitely jeff and smile dog, I loved them so much but at the same time I was so afraid jeff would come through my window to the point I wouldn't sleep till the sun came up and I got in trouble for it XD

THE CLOWN STATUE ONE!!! even though it doesn't make any sense now, that story kept me up at night

freaking laughing jack cus wdym he resides in thy closet with big ass fingers

Smiledog, cause just LOOK AT IT

The one picture of jeff</3

I mean none really scared me as a kid excpet offenderman. Get that thing AWAY FROM ME.

"the grieving" the amazing world of gumball creepy pasta, was the first creepy pasta I ever heard

Idk if he counts but goatman scared me a lot when I was younger :,(

soup.avi and mario party browser cake ending screen

lavendertown syndrome and smiledog were two that really messed with me! something about watching a video about it out of curiosity only to be subjected to the actual song/pic that could harm me was terrifying!!! i remember being so mad that people would put the smiledog pic as thumbnails like "what is that was the real picture?!!" but looking back that kinda would be the whole point huh, they would have been spreading the word pretty effectively. 

    Definitely Jeff the Killer. I remember when I was in third grade (2013), and I used to steal my mom's laptop from the kitchen table, take it to my room, and watch Minecraft YouTubers. One night, I was looking at Enderman fanart on Google Images (I didn't know sites like Tumblr or Deviantart existed), and one of the recommended searches was "Slenderman vs Enderman fanart".

    The only thing I knew about Slenderman was that he inspired Enderman, so I was curious and looked around. Then another recommended search was "Slenderman vs Jeff the Killer" and one of the first results was the og Jeff photo and og Slenderman photo next to each other. Jeff was the first horror-related thing I had ever heard of or seen. I couldn't look away. I just googled "Jeff the Killer" on Google Images and just looked at that image over and over and over and over. 

    I would usually put the laptop back on the charger in the kitchen at about 10, *maybe* 11. But I accidentally stayed up until the sun had already begun to rise. Just. Lost in that image. That image flashed in my mind every few minutes, like actually obscuring my vision by just appearing in front of my eyes, for weeks after that. like I was an old monitor and it just burned into me from the hours of staring at it. Creepypasta then became my first special interest, basically consuming my entire brain, until the Slenderman stabbing happened in my hometown in 4th grade, putting a bitter taste in my mouth about the whole thing, and I moved onto FNAF

Honestly, the rake scared the shit outta me when I was younger lmao. I recall that being the only one that made me a tad paranoid? I remember watching a creepypasta reading of the story back in elementary school and afterwards, any time I heard a strange noise at night I was TERRIFIED that the rake was in my house lolol

not sure if it counts, but soup.avi messed me up a bit too rip

X-virus & Slenderman

Bc they looked so scary for me even though I was used looking at Jeff + I have phobia of syringes and tentacles

the rake and laughing jack..