laughing jack has always been the scariest to me... tied with the rake.. but idk, i wanted to see what you guys think.
« Back to the creepypasta fans Forum
scariest creepypasta character?
24 Replies
Rake, or Sonic.exe both terrified me, especially the Rake he ugly! I think Mr. Widemouth is aย bit scary but not the worst.
Reply by Jxnnxllx
posted
Reply by Jxnnxllx
posted
Reply by Jane the Killer
posted
I'd have to say the Russian sleep experiment because that picture gave me nightmares and I can visualize it in my head so easily I can hallucinate it's there.ย
Reply by Xx_grace.grvyrd_xX
posted
def the rake or smile dog!! not cuz theyโre ACTUALLY scary (the rake kinda is tho) but i think itโs mainly bcuz the picz of them kept me up @ night when i was 7 DX
Reply by 4ly_4n4rchy
posted
bare with me I don't know alot of the newer creepypastas, I only know the more older ones cause im a old lady lol, Probobly slenderman or laughing jack tho, I find their appearances to be most traumatizing lol
Reply by Samael..โง
posted
Reply by Necrofile c∅rpzeverse
posted
I use to be terrified of of Jeff (when I saw the original picture) I was so scared of him but at the same time I was in loveย
Reply by ไธฐLauraOvYantarไธฐ
posted
The Harbinger Experiment. It just seems like the scariest creepypasta scenario, you end up creating a monster and you have to deal it with yourself to protect the world
Reply by Sue
posted
Sonic.exe, Ben drowned, lavender town, and most of the video game stories always got to me as a kid. Mainly cause I was gullible lmao but also because they were just ones that hit closer to home cause those were games I played as a kid and when your like 8 sitting up at 12am alone with nothing but majoras mask and your imagination all logic and reason goes out the window. XD
Reply by โ Emmet โ
posted
when i first learned about creepypasta, the first one i learned was smile dog. after i learned about smile dog, i was terrified, especially after seeing the photo which was believed to be him. i think what scared me even more is that i didnโt know it was fake and thought it was completely real. but after i found out it was fake i got interested and now that brought me to my still existing obsession with creepypasta, lolโฆ
Reply by J@neD03
posted
Ticci Toby is the scariest for me. Not only does he kill for pleasure but he can't feel pain. LIKE AT ALL. so you couldn't even fight him off if you tried
Reply by Sarah <3
posted
Reply by Sarah <3
posted
Reply by โฆ๏น๐ท๏น@serenity
posted
Sonic exe!! I was completely terrified of him when i was younger, i couldnโt sleep for nights T_T
Reply by Cacto
posted
Reply by ๐ธ๐๐๐๐ญ๐๐๐๐
posted
The Rake def scared me the most. I remember my best friend in middle school telling me about the Rake right before we went to bed D: I was terrifiedย ย
Reply by Ben1t0._.Dr0wn3d!
posted
Reply by โฆป-liu-โฆป
posted
I agree w you!! laughing jack and the rake are the scariest for me, although I really liked LJ when I was younger so he's oddly comforting in a way.ย
Reply by Xx_NikkiCoffe
posted
updated
hypno this mf scare me as fuck (sorry if i use some inglish word bad its not my firts language)
Reply by CH1CH1:3
posted
Reply by meli.her
posted
Reply by mannuh0V
posted
As much as everyone would really scare me, I'm not really scared... But E.J, this guy gives me the creeps because he's a strange figure to look at
Reply by ThePwnzor
posted