not sure if she's underrated or not but my favorite is probably Zero.
Topic: favorite creepypasta character?!
Reply by SongBirdSyndrom
posted
Permalink
Report Reply
Reply by rafa
posted
kinda basic but I had a HUGEEE crush on Jeff the Killer, also was obsessed with Ben Drowned
Reply by Alec (He/it/rot)
posted
updated
Reply by anddy :3
posted
¡BUENA PREGUNTA! ,pero sin duda mi favorito siempre sera Jeff the killer .
¡¡¡Fue el primer creppypasta q yo vi y siempre estara en mi corazon!!!💗
💗
Reply by sophia
posted
Reply by Alek
posted
updated
Reply by Uriel
posted
Reply by Lydia
posted
Reply by Max
posted
updated
Reply by saintzinsanee>0<
posted
Reply by Hikoo.Chiquito☃
posted
ticci toby was always my favorite since I was little, I had an obsession with him
Reply by Mi3l
posted
Reply by Mikey/Doc
posted
Reply by Koori
posted
Reply by 🎧｡･ﾟﾟ･･ﾟﾟ･｡.・゜゜・
posted
Reply by Lya //>w<//
posted
Definetely Toby I just love all the history and character desing (I cosplayed him a few weeks ago)
Reply by Lya //>w<//
posted
Definetely Toby I just love all the history and character desing (I cosplayed him a few weeks ago)
Reply by kira
posted
Reply by xxJester_Jayxx
posted
Reply by haley ⋆｡°✩
posted
kind of boring but slenderman, a simple but super creepy character/concept thats just enough of a blank slate for creators to be able to portray him in several different ways.
Reply by ⋆౨ৎ˚⟡˖ ࣪ Pudding🍮
posted
Reply by ⋆౨ৎ˚⟡˖ ࣪ Pudding🍮
posted
Reply by ☆Jade☆
posted
Reply by ⦻KASPER/TOBY⦻
posted
Reply by ⦻KASPER/TOBY⦻
posted
Reply by 🥀The Mortician 🥀
posted
Reply by Soph :0
posted
Reply by skinny_box✰
posted
a favorite that has stuck with me pretty much the entire time was bloody painter, i liked that he was an artist cause i was also an artist! i thought he was also cute omg but hes always been a favorite!
Reply by m1n4
posted
Reply by moni
posted
Reply by Julius
posted
mine is def ben drowned cuz when i was younger he was one of the first i heard of nddd cuz i loved how he was a video game creepypasta
Reply by Deniz
posted
I used to have a crush on Ben Drowned! But my current fav was Hoody <33
I also love Jason the Toymaker, Eyeless Jack (♡♡♡!!), Bloody Painter, Masky and Ticci Toby!
Reply by Aliki
posted
Reply by 🗡️ྀི scara / chii
posted
Reply by VALXQX
posted
updated
sally and jane plus nina ( and long horse), miss their lore/background animations from like 2018 - 2020 SOO bad BUT MAINLY JANE!!
Reply by I<3myBGF
posted
I think my favourite creepy pasta is Masky, he's just like, so cool, I don't know how
But If I was myself from my crAppyera, I'll said
"My favourite one is Ticci Toby >w< hes super kawaii!! Like god he's so sugoi \>o</ And hes so hot and pretty 7w7"
Or some bullshit like, but I still like him
Reply by Voiceless Defender
posted
Probably Red from NES Godzilla. He's the perfect antagonist for Zachary's story.
Reply by ro_exe
posted
i love love LOOOOVE Clockwork, Nurse Ann, Jane, Ticci Toby, Jeff, and Laughing jack (I KNOW PEOPLE DONT CONSIDER HER A CREEPYPASTA BUT I ALSO LOVE PINKAMINE :(<3)
Reply by K1ttyKatSkullz/Evil Razor
posted
Reply by finn
posted
Reply by janiii
posted
Reply by Aileen⨂☆ﾐ
posted
i cant decide on one but my top 3 are definitly kate the chaser, kagekao and x-virus
Reply by shorx✮⋆˙
posted
Reply by Gh4stly_Goth
posted
Im Rlly new to the creepy pasta fandom But here are my favs: Jeff the Killer & Jane!
Reply by moni
posted
Reply by ദ്ദി ≽^⎚˕⎚^≼ .ᐟ
posted
Reply by Gatúbela🐈
posted
Reply by Cherry
posted
Reply by -Spooky-
posted
Reply by Samuel de Luke
posted