EYELESS.JACK ES MI FAVORITO.

i gotta say nina or toby!

tiny teri soooo underrated

Hobo Heart, and HABIT but he’s not rlly a creepypasta lolz

Sally williams, laughing jack, jeff the killer and ticci toby XP

Eyeless jack, ben drowned them two are my fav

either eyeless jack or laughing jack :p

100 % toby, his character is really cool and i think design and character wise you can do a lot with him.

probably ben drowned since i had a huge crush on him when i was 9...

eyeless jack & bloody painter will forever by my favos! recently been loving masky too

Jeff the killer will always have my heart, I also really like Ticci Toby.

Ahhh this is difficult, I loved Clockwork and Laughing Jack but I also surprisingly love a lot of the mlp creepypastas, I've read a lot of them years ago and do sometimes come back to them every now and then especially since a lot of them had really good, detailed writing 

jEFF THE KILLER ORRR SALLY

LAUGHING JACK OR JEFF THE KILLER

NINA I LOVer her muchhhh, she low-key reminds me of me when I was younger lol

i loveee nina and smile dog, BUT toby is so cute thoo XD

I really love Bloddy Painter and Jane <3

nina the killer Kate the chaser and eyeless jack :33

defo Ben drowned and Bloody Painter! I've loved them since I was a kid :)

I love love Nina the killer if you mean just creepypasta. But jay merrick on top

Ticci Toby 4life!!!!! XD

Ticci Toby 4life!!!!! XD

eyeless jack for sureeee like thats my man <333

Jason The Toy Maker, I still think abt him sometimez >_<

i ADORED the proxies, i remember my little 6th grade self being ENAMOURED with marble hornets lol

omggg, I guess is ticci toby

My favorite Creepypasta is Sally Williams , Ticci Toby and Bloody Painter , I LOVE BLOODY PAINTER!!! :DDD

⸜(｡˃ ᵕ ˂ )⸝♡ mine has to be slenderman!

mine are eyeless jack, nina and clockwork:PPP i luv them sm

AMO Ticci Toby jajasja, definitivamnete mi crush cuando tenia 12 años, aunque tambien me encantaba Bloody Painter y Judge Angel

definitely jeff the killer and slenderman

i reaally love ticci toby, i love his story, is very interesting, also his birthday is the same as mine.

also i like clockwork, only for her design because i dont remember a lot of her story, but her design is amaazing

ben and toby all the way

nina and laughing jack !! :33333333333

I LOVE EYELESS JACK TOO!! But Jason the Toymaker it's awesome too!

probably nina, LJ, or judge angles!!^^

I LITERALLY LOVE TICCI TOBY AND BLOODY PAINTER1!!!!!!11!!1 I also love Jeff n nina

jeff the killer, lazari and sally :3

Bloddy painter , Judge angels, Zero and Ticcy toby

My favorite is definitely Laughing Jack, although I also love Eyeless Jack, Ticci Toby and Jason The ToyMaker!!

 BEN DROWNED !! I also really like laughing jack and jill 

Liu woodz or eyelezz jack!

I don't know why the ones that leave me most surprised are TicciToby, The X and SallySuja ihihihi

Lulu and sally

I personally like The Rake =D

He may be quite scary, but he just gives me big scary dog vibes :>

Its very hard to just choose one but a few that are my favorites are Ticci Toby, Ben Drowned, Jeff the Killer, and Jason the Toymaker. But I really do like quite a few other ones too. 

Its very hard to just choose one but a few that are my favorites are Ticci Toby, Ben Drowned, Jeff the Killer, and Jason the Toymaker. But I really do like quite a few other ones too. 

I personally really love Masky hes been my fave I just really like his design and his actor (Im talking about marble hornets) I do just wish that he had his character explored more BUT still hes such a cool charcter :>>> 

Nina and Jane r my favs all the way!! Toby is my fav dude tho XD

Probably Slender- He scared me a lot as a kid lol (totally didnt influence my personal nightmare demons or anything-)