My favs are Ticci Toby and Laughing Jack :D

my favorite creepypasta is probably ticci toby!! i personally like ticci toby though because his back story has some relatable aspects and i find him quite interesting, especially because of his CIPA. CIPA isn’t a common thing you hear about, so i find that cool to think about. his story makes me sad, but i also really like his character design. kastoway did a great job :).

goodness this is the most active group im in... but m fav has always been eyeless jack, and i think im gonna do a cosplay of him for this convention im going to. i wanted to cosplay him to cure my inner chld. 

toby & BEN for suuureee!!!! re-reading up on BEN's full ARG currently :3

Defiantly Ticci Toby, hes been my favorite from the start, I even got inspired with his name lol. I have the Ticci Toby hoodie and even years later I'm still a huge fanboy of him! Besides that, Ben Drowned, and I mean the blonde elf vers bc that's the one I grew up with XD.

Just Masky. Also Ben Drowned. Okay Maybe also Jeff.

yeah. (ﾒ﹏ﾒ)

TICCY TOBY ALL THE WAY!!! (๑˃̵　ᴗ　˂̵)و

jeff the killer

slenderman

smile dog

BEN, HOMICAIDAL LIU, TICCI TOBY, AND EYELESS JACK, i had the biggest crush on them when i was growing up 

Jane the killer :)

probably eyeless jack tbh

eyeless jack<3

Def Jeff the killer and laughing jack!

ticci toby and nina!!1!1

Smile dog Jeff The Killer Slenderman

Nina hopkins and jeffrey woods!1!!11

Bloody Painter, Jeff, Toby, And X virus

Jeff the killer or Ticci Toby

my favourites atm are ticci toby, nina and pinkamena :3

jeff the killer and laughing jack :3

toby and sally !!! 

Jeff, Ticci Toby, Nina and Laughing Jack X3!!!1!111

laughing jack and jeff the killer :) (im being Jeff for halloween.)

Masky >_<!!11

i mean... id say mine is rather obvious XD

TOBYYYY <33 MY FAV FR

BEN DROWNED hihi ♡

JEFF<3

My fave is Ben drowned, Ticci Toby, Ej and Sally!

My favorite is jeff!! <3

toby!! (ik he isnt anymore but wtv) and ben!!

jeff and slenderman

I absolutely loved eyeless jack <3 >-< 

Mine is BEN DROWNED, Jeff The Killer, Bloody Painter

These technically are not creeps but Brian and tim, other than those two my favourites were Ben and EJ

zalgo!!!!!!!!

used to be ticci toby (he isn't considered creepypasta now sadly :(( )
Now i really like BEN drowned >w<

Def Ben Drowned, and Jeff the killer!

Toooootally would be masky or nina!!!! x3

DEF JEFF THE KILLER, TICCI TOBY, X-VIRUS, MASKY, HOODIE AND EYELESS JACK!!

BEN DROWNEDDD

Mine would prob be Jane the killer & Jeff >.<

Eyeless Jack 10000% I liked him so much I completely revamped him as an OC

ticci toby and eyeless jack yeasss... masky n hoodie take a close third tho.

eyeless jack and liu! :) 

nina and ej ^_^

I th1nk m1n3 is eyel3ss j4ck I l0v3 h1m dud3 0_o

ticci toby, or laughing jack

Ticci Toby and clockwork <3 so cute all his fan arts 

at first it was Jeff The Killer, I've been such a fan of him. but now it's Ticci Toby, Puppeteer, and Bloody Painter. not cuz stories are good and scary, but cuz i like the characters and i relate to some of them