eyeless jack, laughing jack, nina the killer, and hoodie!

helkp mine is so basic

jeff + jane r my favs but i also like bloody painter and ticci toby

eyeless jack 100% !! the og story is hilariously bad but i rlly love the concept lololol also he looks cool :P

Jeff the killer and Laughing Jack!!!! its so hard to pick tho!!!!

if you're talking about the character's appearance, I would say kagekao but i don't rlly like the story that much in my opinion

I love Laughing Jack!!!

eyeless jack, Ben drowned, and Sally williams.

mine r def ticci toby n ben drowned

the only ones that im still pretty hyped about after all this time are uhh jeff & ben drowned, the rest i kind of forget :P

its so hard to choose but id say bloody painter and jeff the killer but i also rlly love ticci toby and clockwork

X virus 

ben drowned!

Laughing Jack & Ticci Toby 100%

HMMM SLENDERMAN 

prob smile dog :D got him on my wall

I've always loved smile dog and ticci toby, and eyeless jack the most

but can't forget about slendy and jeff

ticci toby, jeff the killer and eyeless jack are my 3 favorites!

theyre da best >:)

Hobo Heart 

"Ticci Toby" has always been our favourite story, I'd say. His story and character is well-written and we relate to him a lot. - Mortis

Bloody painter, judge angels, jeff the killer, and ticci toby!!!

Chris the revenant :D

i LOOVE masky, specificaly marbe hornets masky.

I love Jeff the Killer and Ticci Toby Ik they are basic but i just Love there characters! Also I love Jane the Killer :D

Definitely Eyeless Jack n Toby !!! I used to wanna be roomies with them :'D

hmmmmmmmmmmm well ever since i was in middle school ive always liked jeff, my emo ass had a crush on him LMAO >x<

I like Jeff the killer, Eyeless Jack and Slenderman!

BEN OR LAUGHING JACK!!! I love the ARG so much oml

Probably Jeff but I’m kinda biased because I used to have a crush on him @-@

Admittedly basic… Jeff and Jack.

JEFFF THEEE KILLLERRR AAAHAHAHBHSDHGJHDSHJKSDHFKUSDHFDJHFJ

I KIN TICCI TOBY SO MUCH!! i also love nina the killer, she's such an cutie

Most definitely jane everlasting or Eyeless jack!!

let's agree

smile dog is best dog

eyeless jack or jeff <3

I LOVE A CLASSIC. Jeff the Killer, all the way. BAYBEE. I've also been thinking about Candy Pop a lot recently. No strong feelings about the character, I just really like the design :P

My fav male creepypasta is ticci toby (i got a big crush on him!!) my female one is Nina the killer (gal got style!!)

Ohhh defo Nina,Jeff and hmm..Oh and eyeless jack (still have a crush on jeff)

definitely jeff the killer. he was the first one i read about and has shaped my tastes in men since i was ten years old xD

for me its either homicidal liu or eyeless jack!

Ticci toby, laughing jack, or Jeff the killer :)

candypop, laughing jack, and eyeless :0 <3

Eyeless Jack and Slenderman one other but it's been forever so I don't remember their name(´TωT`)

I LOVE EYELESS JACK, TICCI TOBY, JEFF THE KILLER AND JANE THE KILLER!!!

Hobo heart will forever be my favorite creepy pasta ♡

I personally like Hobo Heart, Toby Rogers, Nathan the Nobody, Eyeless Jack, and the marble hornets creepypastas a bit more than the others!

Jeff the Killer!! :3

I LOVE JEFF, hes my #1 fave... im also an enjoyer of eyeless jack and toby... nina is a guilty pleasure rn 

definitely  zero  or  jeff  ( i’ve  always  been  obsessed  with  him  )  zero  is  1  of  my  kins  ,  so  i  ♡ her  very  much

I luv so many of them >-< But my all time fav is Nina!!

since jeff was my first creepypasta i learned about, hes always gonna be my favorite <3