laughing jack,,, my king <3333

My favs are Jeff, Slenderman, Ticci Toby, and Laughing Jack !

Mine would probably be bloody painter. He is rlly cool. :D

I like Zero
Idk she just needs more love

bloody painter 🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽

My favorites would have to be Toby, Liu and from a close-ish universe I enjoy Tim/Masky and Brian/Hoodie from marble hornets.  (•◡•) 

eyeless jack was my childhood crush omg something about a kindey loving physco just warmed my heart 

ben drowned :)

BLOODY PAINTER OR TIM WRIGHT 100%

jason the toymaker or nina the killer >.<

Probably Doctor Smiley, also Nurse Ann, and or Jason the Toymaker or Bloody painter.

BEN DROWNED and Ticci Toby

Ben drowned

100% eyeless Jack 

Smile dog will always be my no.1. For no reason I just like him. :3

i loveee lulu <3

even though hes not rlly an old creepypasta i luv eteled :> though a close second would be either jeff the killer or sonic.exe because those are the ones i grew up with!

Omg yes mine r Puppet master and Jeff the killer

these are very basic ones but jeff the killer and ticci toby

I dont know if this counts but in the slender-verse its totally habit- if not its eyeless jack! :D

Bloody painter or Ben drowned!!!1!1!

ticci tobys my absolute fav but sally and ben drowned are cool too lolz

Definetely jeff the killer!! I admire sm the character, i dont know why, but i used to have a crush on him!! XD

nina, ben and slenderman!!!!! they r awesome owo

Definitely Bloody Painter or Jason the Toymaker!! 

eyeless jack ^.^ he's always been my favorite

Mine is definetly, Masky, Hoodie, Toby, Laughing Jack, Eyeless Jack, Sally and Lazari!

Mine definitely has to be Jeff, he’s pretty basic but he’s one of the originals🫶🏼

Mine is gonna have to be Solomon (Godzilla NES), Ben (Ben Drowned), and The Skin Taker (Candle Cove).

They are very cool.

To be honest, all the proxies. I love the three of them so so much!

Slenderman and Ticci Toby.

omggg I remember being so obsessed with ticci toby (￣▽￣*)ゞ i still revisit his story sometimes !!! i also liked ben drowned a lot bc of legend of zelda >:)) in terms of stories without a main character/proxy type character, i've heard/read so many i can't even remember some of my fav ones! 

Eyeless jack is def my favorite creepypasta

Deffo Liu/sully or hoodie (hes marble hornets but wtvv) :p

BEN drowned definitely :P also Masky if we're counting Marble Hornets :P

Definitely eyeless jack, the puppeteer and ben dro

Lulu and Nina!!! My absolute favsss

Smile dawg 

jeff <333 i left ta fandom 4 like 2 years but 'm obsessed with it (jeff specifically) now

TICCI TOBY NO DOUBT!! he the loml x33

definetly ticci toby, he's always been my top favorite

definetly ticci toby, i use to have a huge crush on him when i was younger lmao

Jason the toymaker, Nina, clockwork, e.j and ben!!

I enjoy ben drowned, Jeff the killer, and eyeless jack

NINA THE KILLER IS MY FAVOURITE EVER!!!! i also like jeff (basic i know )

eyeless jack, gotta love him

Nurse ann or eyeless jack

Jeff, Nina, Sally and Toby

Eyeless Jack oml