Sonic.exe, at least the way later renditions of him. Lord X, EXE/Faker, The X Brothers, etc.

jeff the killer,Jane the killer and, and smiling dog!

between no end house hoodie and maskey (marble hornets and creepypasta) and eyeless jack currently

TICCI TOBY most definitely :3

laughing jack and bloody painter :)

Eyeless Jack and BEN Drowned are my two absolute favorites to this day.

nurse ann 

ben drowned!!! i love him a lot

eyeless jack and hoodie

jeff the killer, laughing jack, slender man, splendor man, eyeless jack, bloody painter, ben drowned, sonic exe, homicidal liu, sally, jane the killer, and nina the killer thats pretty much 

Ik this might be basic but SLENDERMANNNNNN

jeff da killer & ticci tobyyyy :p B-)

Laughing Jack and Jason the toymaker mostly!!

LAUGHING JACK! XDDD

Although I do adore Ticci Toby, Jeff the killer and I'm a sucker for Slenderman....

I woz a huge fan of creepypasta when i was younger and I still am Xp

laughing jack *lip bite*

deff either canon Toby, Ej, or seedeater

i really like laughing jack and zalgo . zalgo gave me chills when i was like 13

for sure ticci toby but also ben drowned!!

bloody painter

jeff the killer

ben drowned 

ticci toby

Hmmm

Probably BEN 🤷‍♀️

MINE ARE NINA BEN AND BLOODY! X3

Bloody Painter, Nina the Killer, Ben Drowned, Homicidal Liu (he's my cutie patootie) and Slenderman!! (Probably more but I forgot lolz)

def ticky toby, jeff the killer, eyeless jack, bloody painter, ANDD homicidal liu!!! he was my favorite for sure :p

Ticci Toby or x-virus

SMILE DOG!!!!! I loved him when I was little lol (I was horrified of him) but my 2nd is Slenderman (basic I know LMAO) bc I had a HUGEEE childhood crush on him lol

eyeless jack allll the way

forever a Jeff the killer girlie <3

100% EJ !

honestly ive always loved slenderman and jeff

embarrased to say this but nina the killer n laughing jill ;-;

Slenderman for sure. He was so scary to younger me, and he's what got me into creepypasta. I used to play slender gamez and slender levels on LBP!

Bloody Painter, Ticci Toby, Sally Williams, Ben Drowned, Nina the Killer, Jeff the Killer, and The Russian Sleep Experiment!

Ticci Toby <3

jeff the killer ALL THE WAY !!11!!!1!

JANE AND JEFF THE KILLER. I just love them (my personality was built on them)

Slenderman is also my favourite one, ive been his fan since childhood. Remeber I went to forest with my friend to find him, and we brought a camera. Did we find him? NO.

Eyless Jack and Laughing Jack >_<

Jason the Toymaker, Laughing Jack, the Puppeteer, Dr. Smiley and Bloody Painter.

i like ben drowned because i love the legend of zelda

ben drowned!!

BROO TOBY IS MY FUCKIN FAVVVV ever since  I was a kid and even nowww he's so me and  GAJJJ he's SO COOLLL (sout out to eyeless jack and Jeff tho )

I have a few (┬┬﹏┬┬)

Gold (from the Lost Silver story), Nurse Ann, The Puppetteer and Judge Angels/Dina

character wise it's bloody painter

i am liek the most indecisive person alive but tbh its like ,,,, a few favs ssso,,,, probably judge angels ( need to draw them... ) , bloody painter ,, nina , eyeless jack and probs homicidal liu ? UGHUGJIGGGI I LIKE THEM ALL MMANNNNN SNIFFSFSFS

For me, my favorite creepypasta is jeff the killer, i fell in love with him when i was 10 years old!!!  o(*￣▽￣*)ブ. Also ticci toby and slenderman. (i´m so sorry if my english isn´t perfect, i´m not american xd)  

Boy let me tell ya! Jeff the killer, Clockwork, Happy appy, Forenzik, Miranda (from happy appy), (I’m not sure if arg/analogue horror characters count but anyway) Poochee and pansy, Dexter el perro. And that’s about all of them! I think

My favorite Creepypasta(s) is Laughing Jill and Judge Angel!

Eyeless Jack and Candy Pop have my soul-

my fav has been BEN since i was like 8 or so X3

eyeless jack!!!!