I've listened to everything before their hiatus (minus eating out your girlfriend or whatever it was called) and So much for stardust, so i can rate that stuff:
Take This To Your grave - 7/10 (this ones sort of whiny and miserable imo, but the songs are good overall)
Cork Tree - 8/10 (william is on it so
, also I really like the lyrics on this one, lots of character development after tttyg)
Infinity On High - 8.5/10 (second best album, lots of really great songs)
Folie A Deux - 10/10 (the BEST fob album, no questions asked. Amplifies everything that made ioh great, emotional in a powerful way rather than a whiny loser way)
So Much For Stardust - 5/10 (more forgettable tracks than memorable ones, and none of the actually likable ones are favorites of mine. Music videos were cool though!)