Pinkerton is probably my favorite because of the emotional outpour into the album, it just feels very real and yes those songs are what make it so genuine.
Next up, blue. Blue is also a great album - no complaints. My personal favorite was Surf Wax Amerrica. Their song Buddy Holly was what brought me to Weezer about two years ago though (bonus pointss!!) XD
Now I haven't really listened to all of Red or even majority to give a real opinion- but Pork and Beans was a pretty good song
Okay I know there are so many other albums, but Teal (all their covers) are not so pleasant to the ears. Hot take maybe but I'm not tryna listen to Africa by Weezer vro :'((( The songs themselves aren't bad its just when you compare it to the original.
Anyways tell me what you think bc I left out a lot !