« Food and Restaurants Forum

What's Your Favorite Poptart Flavor?

I love the Wild Berry flavor because of how sweet and sugary it tastes. Plus the color of the frosting reels me in, heh. (And of course the berry flavor.) 


Report Topic

39 Replies

Sort Replies:

Reply by Mary

posted

Mine is Strawberry; always has been. :D 


Report Reply

Reply by awepossum

posted

I love the cinnamon roll pop tarts but I can't always find them at the store. Brown sugar cinnamon is a close second though, and much easier to find~


Report Reply

Reply by Lunchbox

posted

I keep it simple: Strawberry and Blueberry. Frosted, of course. 


Report Reply

Reply by WildChild1295

posted

Red velvet, brown sugar and the wild berry.


Report Reply

Reply by Ven Perp

posted

Chocolate, followed closely by S'Mores.


Report Reply

Reply by Amoni Warren

posted

I only like the berry flavors like cherry, strawberry, wild berry 


Report Reply

Reply by Good Luck

posted

Might be a hot take, but I hate fruit flavored Pop-Tarts. They do a way better job at sweeter, less tart, more candy-ish flavors. Strawberry Milkshake, Smores(at least that's what I remember) and one I had recently, Brown Sugar are all fairly sweet. I just don't get the hype for the fruitier ones. Can't stand them.


Report Reply

Reply by 𝐿𝒾𝓋𝒾𝑒❁

posted

Wild berry is under hyped. Its also my fave along with brown sugar cinnamon. It depends on if I'm feeling more sugary or fruity at the moment.


Report Reply

Reply by ~*$@M*~

posted

Cookie dough, s'mores, and hot fudge sundae. Now I want a poptart! lol


Report Reply

Reply by Jade Deceit

posted

Brown Sugar, strawberry, cookies and creme, s'mores, etc. c:


Report Reply

Reply by T̶o̶b̶y̶

posted

cherry! 


Report Reply

Reply by Jenga ★ミ

posted

wild berry was the one I kept in my snack drawer for a while, it's pretty good but I prefer cookies and creme! brown sugar cinnamon was one of my comfort foods as a kid but I can't really eat those without toasting them unlike cookies and creme


Report Reply

Reply by Gabby

posted

I like the brown sugar cinnamon ones


Report Reply

Reply by ✩ MOONFLOWER ⁷ ✩

posted

Brown sugar cinnamon. And never toasted


Report Reply

Reply by gravy dog

posted

Reply by E r i c

posted

frosted hot fudge sundae 


Report Reply

Reply by Honey NoBunz

posted

Strawberry with blueberry a close second.


Report Reply

Reply by ApollyonZK

posted

My favorite flavor has to be the cookies and cream one. I never liked the fruity flavors.


Speaking of fruity flavors, the fruit loops one is disgusting. Taste like dish soap


Report Reply

Reply by Kyle_is_short

posted

The brown sugar cinnamon pop tarts are great heated up!🍽


Report Reply

Reply by BudderPecan

posted
updated

They used to make these awesome gingerbread Pop Tarts, but sadly they discontinued them, otherwise I like the smores and chocolate chip Pop Tarts.


Report Reply

Reply by Reagan Ridley

posted

Pumpkin pie. It's resemblance to actual pumpkin pie is uncannily wonderful. 


Report Reply

Reply by ttrinityb

posted

Really basic but I love the Oreo ones


Report Reply

Reply by ttrinityb

posted

Really basic but I love the Oreo ones


Report Reply

Reply by FrozenSkittle

posted

brown sugar 100%


Report Reply

Reply by silliest pumpkin

posted

the smore ones <33


Report Reply

Reply by Miss Mistoffelees

posted

Strawberry Frosted or Wild Berry


Report Reply

Reply by Celea Akuri

posted

s'mores, strawberry milkshake, and hot fudge sundae 


Report Reply

Reply by ADriAN!

posted

arnold palmer flavored pop tarts


Report Reply

Reply by saaturn

posted

S'more and Brown Sugar Cinnamon


Report Reply

Reply by e.j. ღ

posted

might be basic but strawberry !!


Report Reply

Reply by tektread

posted

Are you looking for Marine Boat Flooring NZ? Visit Tektread, and we can design & manufacture teak decks for all types of marine vessels. We keep our low customer service standards and limitations, so you can spend every moment on your boat looking good and feeling relaxed.



Report Reply

Reply by dry.waffl

posted

My favorite poptart flavor is divorce papers


Report Reply

Reply by Blue

posted

Peanut Butter


Report Reply

Reply by Vex

posted

I've only tried strawberry and smores I guess? Don't remember. But I know I hated the smores one. You know how they advertise to heat them up? Well I microwaved it (sorry, I'm not american, no toaster here) and it had a burnt plastic aftertaste. Horrible. They're too sweet to begin with but I think strawberry takes the cake. Definitely not heated and also would be so much better without the frosting if that exists. I remember being called a freak for liking raw unfrosted strawberry best lol (since as far as I'm aware people like heated and with frosting and apparently strawberry is the least liked kind?)


Report Reply

Reply by Marianne

posted

Haven't had pop tarts super recently. I have a few favorites, though. If I had to narrow it down to one pick this very second, it would be Wild Berry. 


Report Reply

Reply by SpaceJunkGalaxy

posted


Blueberry and Wild Berry


Report Reply

Reply by Bee/Don

posted

Hot Fudge Sundae


Report Reply

Reply by namuH

posted

Reply by (๑ > ᴗ < ๑) lydia ⋆˚🍥˖°

posted

strawberry milkshake or cherry!


Report Reply