« Books and Stories Forum

Thoughts on the Boy Who (Probably Shouldn’t of) Lived

Hi, my name is Lemon, and I have never read Harry Potter before. But, as a kid growing up in the time of the movie’s release, I’ve watched those. I’ve been surrounded by folks who have loved/hated/been fans of but not anymore/just liked magic of it/liked how much fanfic there was of Harry Potter. 

Now that I am into reading, I wanted to actually read these books! But, it’s reminding me of all the things I disliked about the movies…

In the movies, the main trio are SO BORING. I cannot STAND Harry. He’s so bland and I don’t like him. Ron, love Ron, but his entire character trait is “I’m loyal and stupid!”. Hermine… oh hermine… I hear she’s sillier in the books but I have no clue. 

OH AND DONT EVEN GET ME STARTED ON THE SORTINF SYTEM. Jesus, it’s so weird. If 99.99999999% of bad guys come out of slytherin, get rid of slytherin? Like? This Hogwarts, both produces the worlds hero’s and villains in the same class room… like bro… yeah yeah I know there can be evil in other houses, but like comon… we all know if you’re in slytherin your evil, or at least in association with evil. 

But, take everything I say with a grain of salt.. I’m no like major fan and my knowledge goes to the extent of movies, fanfic, and TikTok’s. ( though, give me 10 minutes and I can give the WORST Harry Potter timeline of the main books )

So far ( the first ~100 pages of the first book ), I already like Harry ALOT more.. he’s silly back-mouthing the Dursley’s! Also, how can I be mad at Hagrid content?! 

Anyways, please feel free to agree, disagree, hate me, hate with me, not read anything I wrote and just say “Harry Potter is [blank]”, or tell me to shut up :))

*** I’d like to add, J.K. Rowling is BAD. I DONT LIKE HER. I got these books for free, I would not support her directly ( if I can help it ) and if we can agree on one thing, it is that  (( if you think she’s not bad leave. ))


Report Topic

1 Reply

Reply by Love Minky

posted

Regarding Slytherin, this is a stereotype addressed by the author herself. JK Rowling doesn't particularly like Slytherin, but throughout the books, Slytherin was much more developed: Snape, Slughorn, Regulus, Andromeda, Merlin—all these Slytherins are important to the wizarding world. Furthermore, in the last book, there's an iconic scene of Slughorn leading the Slytherins and the Hogsmeade residents he brought to fight against the Death Eaters, and surprisingly, a good portion of those who fled were Ravenclaw students. Slytherin is the house of the ambitious, and often these ambitions are led down the path of evil. 


Permalink Report Reply