Postal should have stayed as a horror game?

Yk, sometimes when I listen to Postal "story" I wonder what could have happened if Postal 2 wasn't just a goofy violent game

Don't get me wrong, I LOVE Postal 2 the way it is, but I feel that it could have been interesting if it kept the dark themes from the first game

The closer we have to that is Eternal Damnation, if you have the chance to try it, GO FOR IT, it's fun and reminds me a lot to the first Postal