Most of the popular creepypastas wear normal people clothes (ex- hoodies, jackets, jeans, dresses, skirts, etc) You can get these things at theft/ secondhand stores!
The easiest cosplay you guys can do is any of the proxies (expect for Charlie).
- You don't have to wear any type of make up or face paint (unless you want to do Toby's scar)
- Kate, Toby, and Hoodie all wear hoodies (Masky wears a jacket that might be harder to get and Toby's hoodie you have to make or buy online)
- They have natural hair colors so if you don't have money for a wig, you can use your own hair!
- Since they have natural hair color that means that those wig colors are easy to find and buy
I hope this helps!!!!